Research Article Open Access

Optimal Subsurface Appraisal: A Key Link to the Success of Development Projects-Few Examples

Virendra Singh1, Ivan Yemez1, Elena Izaguirre1 and Alvaro Racero1
  • 1 Repsol, Méndez Álvaro 44, 28045 Madrid, Spain


During exploration and production phases, the life of a hydrocarbon field can be distinguished by five main stages: Exploration, appraisal, development, production and abandonment. Of particular interest is the appraisal stage, where billions of dollars are spent across the oil and gas industry on data gathering activities with a view to reducing subsurface uncertainties towards optimizing reservoir development and management. However, very limited attention is often paid to assessing the Value of Information (VOI) during data acquisition requirement planning, before requesting for such information. Appraisal, when conducted optimally, leads to informed sequential decisions resulting in a development plan that optimizes cost, hydrocarbon recovery and attempts to maximize Net Present Value (NPV). On the contrary, suboptimal appraisal, either in the form of under, or over appraisal, impacts project economics. Individual oil and gas companies use their own strategies, procedures and metrics to optimize subsurface appraisals and safeguard profitability and hence there are no industry standards. The capital intensiveness of the industry and emerging low oil price regime has necessitated scrutiny on every dollar spent on data gathering in the current business terrain. Appraisal should be optimized by way of case specific activity of data acquisition to ensure project deliverability under maximum residual uncertainties achieved by minimum appraisal cost. To ensure that the appraisal strategy is value driven, an effort has been made to briefly recapitulate the different components of appraisal strategy necessary for appraisal framing and evaluation workflow. The appraisal locations selection and their sequencing combines uncertainty reduction, probability of success with VOI technique to determine the number of appraisal wells, their sequence of drilling and their justification that is based on economic merit. The effectiveness of this systematic approach has been illustrated through some real field examples. This workflow along with periodic look-back analysis, during appraisal to development phases, has proven to be highly useful for (1) improving the understanding of geological model; (2) assess VOI from appraisal; (3) reduce subsurface uncertainties and (4) improve decision quality and whole cycle project economics.

American Journal of Applied Sciences
Volume 14 No. 2, 2017, 217-230


Submitted On: 13 June 2016 Published On: 13 January 2017

How to Cite: Singh, V., Yemez, I., Izaguirre, E. & Racero, A. (2017). Optimal Subsurface Appraisal: A Key Link to the Success of Development Projects-Few Examples. American Journal of Applied Sciences, 14(2), 217-230.

  • 4 Citations



  • Subsurface Appraisal
  • Geological Risk
  • Value of Information
  • Development
  • Resources
  • Net Present Value